Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stephen Bailey's avatar

When I was doing my PhD, the idea of “connectomics” was getting pretty big in human brain imaging. (eg https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1220826110) One of the big ideas was “modularity” - how we could identify meaningful subgraphs and interactions between these subgraphs, and to what extent they enabled cognition. So my mind goes there as one axis.

I also see differences in the level of external agency the graph mind has -- the difference between being a node in the matrix, which is actually just a giant battery, vs a node in a race that is trying to accomplish global domination for example.

So,

X-axis: modularity of the graph mind (nodes have no meaningful substructure vs Nodes being a part of a subgraphs that serves a specific purpose)

Y-Axis: Mind Agency (graph mind is purely reflective/self-absorbed vs graph mind is active agent in the world)

Quadrants:

- bottom left: unstructured / low agency -- Compute Machine -- examples, the Matrix battery (not, the AIs themselves I think), Twitter (has emergent substructure, but is fluid)

- top left: unstructured / high agency -- Hive Mind -- examples, StarCraft’s Zerg race (esp the Overmind), Ultron ,

- bottom right: structured / low agency -- collective - Scientific Community (experts contributing knowledge), Reddit

- top right: structured / high agency -- examples, StarCraft’s Protoss race (tribal/stratified but connected), human brain

1 more comment...

Ready for more?